Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?
News:
Pages: [1]   Go Down
Print
This topic has not yet been rated!
You have not rated this topic. Select a rating:
Author Topic: Ship Excavation Sheds Light on Napoleon's Attack on the Holy Land  (Read 538 times)
0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.
Bart
Platinum Member
*****

Karma: 143
OfflineOffline

Posts: 1740



View Profile
« on: March 05, 2007, 10:29:28 PM »

Ship Excavation Sheds Light on Napoleon's Attack on the Holy Land

05-Mar-2007

   A ship that sunk off the coast of Acre during the battles between Napoleon and the British Royal navy is still shrouded in mystery. Marine archaeologists from the University of Haifa are analyzing the hull and the finds in an effort to solve the mystery.

   Which navy commissioned the boat that sunk off the coast of Acre 200 years ago, which battles was it involved in and how did it end up at the bottom of the sea? The recent findings of marine archaeologists at the Leon Recanati Institute for Maritime Studies of the University of Haifa may provide the answers to these questions.

   The ship, which sunk off the coast of Acre during a battle between Napoleon, the British navy and possibly the defenders of Acre, 200 years ago, is under excavation and its finds are beginning to shed light on Napoleon's attempt to conquer the Holy Land.

   Recent marine excavations found cannon balls, canisters of gun powder and other items that will help give evidence as to the ship's journey and answer the questions facing marine archaeologists. It is not clear if the boat was involved in battles in 1799 or 1840, if it was a French or British boat or even if the boat sunk or was sunk. "This is the only shipwreck excavated from the period of the French blockade of Acre and it can teach us a lot about the naval battles of that period," explained Dr. Ya'acov Kahanov from the Leon Recanati Institute for Maritime Studies and the Department Of Maritime Civilizations at the University of Haifa.

   This large ship, 30 meters long and 9 meters wide, was discovered off the Acre coast in 1966, but systematic excavations have only just begun under the auspices of the Leon Recanati Institute for Maritime Studies of the University of Haifa in cooperation with the Nautical Archaeological Societyof Great Britain and with the help of the Nautical College for Naval Officers in Acre. The fact that cannon balls, gun powder canisters, wineskins and metal buckles were found, attest to the fact that this ship was part of a naval fleet. The question of which battle it was involved in has yet to be answered, but the archaeologists do have some theories.

   It seems that the story of this boat begins over 200 years ago. Researchers found a map in a British archive, drawn in 1799 by a British soldier, of the British formation off the coast of Acre, facing a blockade of Napoleon's ships. The map includes a symbol of a sunken ship, at exactly the spot where this ship was found. This map is the source of the theory that this ship was involved in the battles of 1799. In addition, one of the cannon balls was found wedged into the keel of the boat, exactly at the bottom. The location and the unique angle at which the cannon ball is positioned, has led researchers to believe that it was this cannon ball that sank the ship.

   "One of the theories is that this is a "barricade ship" - a ship that the British purposely sunk at the entrance of the port in order to block smaller French ships from entering it. The leather buckles, gun power canisters and the rest of the finds need to be analyzed to verify how the ship ended up at the bottom of the sea. Once we understand these questions, we will be able to understand more about battle tactics of that period, "said Dr. Kahanov.

http://www.newswise.com/articles/view/527843/?sc=rssn
Logged

Learning is a treasure which accompanies its owner everywhere.
Solomon
Guest
« Reply #1 on: March 06, 2007, 02:14:59 AM »

They should ask Doc to identify it, especially if they don't know the navy the ship belonged to.
 Cheesy

I still wonder how the French still worship Napoleon, when this episode is one of a number where he showed no loyalty to his men, nor shame.
 

Solomon
Logged
Bart
Platinum Member
*****

Karma: 143
OfflineOffline

Posts: 1740



View Profile
« Reply #2 on: March 08, 2007, 09:33:42 PM »

OK, here's Doc's chance to identify a claim re: this wreck. Is this really a cannonbal wedged in the keel? Personally, I first thought it was a hedgehog playing soccer, but that can't be, it is underwater.

- Bart

     Cannon ball found wedged into the keel of a ship that sunk during the battles between Napoleon and the British Royal Navy. Credit: Steve Breitstein
Logged

Learning is a treasure which accompanies its owner everywhere.
Diving Doc
Platinum Member
*****

Karma: 104
OfflineOffline

Posts: 1482


Treasure is In books


View Profile WWW
« Reply #3 on: March 09, 2007, 02:37:36 AM »

Bart,
I can't even see a keel or a cannonball just some ribs. Somebody is making a big assumption here. I don't see evidence to support the original statement. Could have been an older wreck that was marked on a chart but................This cannonball on the inside of the hull sank this ship?

It seems that the story of this boat begins over 200 years ago. Researchers found a map in a British archive, drawn in 1799 by a British soldier, of the British formation off the coast of Acre, facing a blockade of Napoleon's ships. The map includes a symbol of a sunken ship, at exactly the spot where this ship was found. This map is the source of the theory that this ship was involved in the battles of 1799. In addition, one of the cannon balls was found wedged into the keel of the boat, exactly at the bottom. The location and the unique angle at which the cannon ball is positioned, has led researchers to believe that it was this cannon ball that sank the ship.

   "One of the theories is that this is a "barricade ship" - a ship that the British purposely sunk at the entrance of the port in order to block smaller French ships from entering it. The leather buckles, gun power canisters and the rest of the finds need to be analyzed to verify how the ship ended up at the bottom of the sea. Once we understand these questions, we will be able to understand more about battle tactics of that period, "said Dr. Kahanov.


Give me a break Dr. Kahanov, you don't even know what questions to ask and you already have the theoretical answers. Unique angle of entry of a round cannonball?? Who are these researchers and where did they get their crystal ball?
The British sank a big ship to keep out smaller French ships?? The "map" is the source of the theory??

Admiralty records are where you begin and this is only 200 years ago so it shouldn't be too difficult, especially if you would like to learn something about British Naval Tactics.
Doc
Logged

Bart
Platinum Member
*****

Karma: 143
OfflineOffline

Posts: 1740



View Profile
« Reply #4 on: March 09, 2007, 06:52:18 AM »

Doc, are you saying the big round object in the center of the photo is not a cannonball? What then might it be?

- Bart
Logged

Learning is a treasure which accompanies its owner everywhere.
Diving Doc
Platinum Member
*****

Karma: 104
OfflineOffline

Posts: 1482


Treasure is In books


View Profile WWW
« Reply #5 on: March 09, 2007, 01:58:51 PM »

Bart,
I'm questioning that that was the cannonball that sank the vessel. Doesn't even look like an embedded cannonball does it? Looks like it might be sitting in what was once the bilge. How, just for starters, would you fire a cannonball into the bottom of the vessel?  Roll Eyes   I don't see any shattered or broken planking. I don't care for all the less than intelligent statements from some one who is supposed to be a scientist. It's not about understanding these questions, it's about getting evidence and finding answers, isn't it ?
"Once we understand these questions, we will be able to understand more about battle tactics of that period, "said Dr. Kahanov".

DUHhhhhhhhh,
Doc
Logged

Bart
Platinum Member
*****

Karma: 143
OfflineOffline

Posts: 1740



View Profile
« Reply #6 on: March 09, 2007, 07:41:58 PM »

Doc, I see what you mean about the cannonball, it doesn't appear to be damaged or to be the culprit of any damage here, just as you say there doesn't appear to be any damage here. And it obviously isn't lodged in the keel either. It makes you wonder who writes these press releases, as in 'what were they thinking?' This is also why I trot these 'horses' out here into the ring, so everybody can take a good look at them to see if they have four legs or not, and if the head is attached to the proper end of the body. Apparently this nag has some serious problems.  Grin

- Bart
Logged

Learning is a treasure which accompanies its owner everywhere.
Diving Doc
Platinum Member
*****

Karma: 104
OfflineOffline

Posts: 1482


Treasure is In books


View Profile WWW
« Reply #7 on: March 09, 2007, 08:08:06 PM »

Bart,
I fail to see how this animal is even standing upright based on the logic of these statements.
Doc
Logged

Bart
Platinum Member
*****

Karma: 143
OfflineOffline

Posts: 1740



View Profile
« Reply #8 on: March 10, 2007, 02:47:33 AM »

Good point Doc, I hadn't thought of that.

- Bart
Logged

Learning is a treasure which accompanies its owner everywhere.
Tags:
Pages: [1]   Go Up
Print
 
Jump to:  

Powered by SMF 1.1.4 | SMF © 2006-2007, Simple Machines LLC
History Hunters Worldwide Exodus | TinyPortal v0.9.8 © Bloc